Now more than ever, hiring the right talent isn’t just important—it’s essential for survival.
But with political winds changing and heightened scrutiny on workplace practices, one interview misstep could cost you more than just a great candidate.
Let me be crystal clear: the stakes in hiring have never been higher.
Reddit flared up over an eyebrow-raising interview question, and now Newsweek’s on the scene with a breakdown of the viral post that asked: ‘So, planning any babies soon?’. The aftermath? A social media firestorm, potential legal exposure, and damage to the company’s reputation that no PR team could easily fix.
This isn’t just about following rules—it’s about protecting your company while still finding that perfect hire in challenging times.
The Changing Rules of Engagement
With a new administration taking the helm and economic uncertainty looming, companies are navigating a complex web of evolving workplace regulations. What was acceptable yesterday might put your company at risk today.
Remember when casual conversations about a candidate’s family or weekend plans seemed harmless? Those days are gone, my friend.
Today’s savvy candidates know their rights, and they’re not afraid to speak up when boundaries are crossed. In fact, according to recent data, employment discrimination filings have increased by 23% over the last year alone.
The bottom line? What you don’t know about proper interviewing techniques can hurt you—and your company’s bottom line.
7 Questions That Could Put Your Company at Risk
Let’s cut through the noise and identify the questions that could spell trouble:
- “Do you have children or plan to start a family soon?“
Why it’s problematic: As highlighted in the Newsweek article, this question disproportionately affects women and could be viewed as pregnancy discrimination.
Ask instead: “This role requires occasional weekend work and travel. Are you able to meet these requirements?”
- “What year did you graduate high school?“
Why it’s problematic: This indirectly asks for age, opening the door to age discrimination claims.
Ask instead: “What relevant experience do you have that prepares you for this role?”
- “Where were you born?” or “Is English your first language?”
Why it’s problematic: Questions about national origin can lead to discrimination claims.
Ask instead: “This position requires fluency in these specific languages. Do you have those skills?”
- “Have you ever been arrested?”
Why it’s problematic: In many states, asking about arrests (versus convictions) is illegal and can disproportionately impact certain groups.
Ask instead: “This position requires a background check. Is there anything you’d like to discuss about that process?”
- “Do you have any disabilities or medical conditions?”
Why it’s problematic: Direct questions about disabilities violate ADA protections.
Ask instead: “This job requires lifting 50 pounds and standing for extended periods. Can you perform these essential functions?”
- “Are you vaccinated?” or “What are your views on vaccination?”
Why it’s problematic: This can potentially violate medical privacy laws and create discrimination issues.
Ask instead: “This position follows specific company health and safety protocols. Are you able to comply with all workplace safety requirements?”
- “Are you married?” or “Who will take care of your children while you’re at work?”
Why it’s problematic: Questions about marital or family status can lead to discrimination claims.
Ask instead: “This position requires working from 8am-5pm. Are these hours compatible with your schedule?”
Beyond Compliance: The Art of Effective Interviewing
Here’s the truth that most won’t tell you: avoiding illegal questions is just the baseline. The real magic happens when you transform your interview process from a legal minefield into a strategic advantage.
In today’s economy, where talent is both scarce and expensive, can you really afford to rely on outdated interview techniques?
Think about it: every time you hire the wrong person, it costs you approximately 30% of their first-year salary. For a $100,000 position, that’s $30,000 down the drain—not to mention the opportunity cost and team disruption.
Strategic Interviewing in Uncertain Times
With recession concerns looming and political shifts affecting business regulations, smart leaders are fortifying their hiring processes now. They recognize that the companies that survive economic downturns are those with the strongest teams.
Consider this: during the last major recession, companies that maintained strategic hiring practices recovered 60% faster than those that implemented hiring freezes or made reactive decisions.
The question isn’t whether you can afford to improve your interview process—it’s whether you can afford not to.**
What separates good companies from great ones during challenging times?
The ability to:
- Identify true talent beyond the resume through structured behavioral interviews
- Predict performance using validated assessment tools
- Minimize hiring biases with standardized processes
- Engage candidates authentically while staying legally compliant
- Move quickly when the right talent appears
The Gateway to Better Hiring
As someone who’s guided countless companies through economic and political shifts, I’ve seen firsthand the difference that strategic interviewing makes.
Take Terri, a VP of Sales at a mid-sized tech company facing 40% turnover. After implementing structured behavioral interviews and using proper assessment tools, her turnover dropped to under 10%, saving the company over $2 million in replacement costs in just one year.
Or Mark, a manufacturing CEO who thought his hiring problems stemmed from “lack of good candidates” until we revamped his interview process. Six months later, productivity increased by 22% with the same headcount.
These aren’t outliers—they’re what happens when you transform interviewing from an administrative task to a strategic advantage.
If recent high-profile cases of interview missteps have you concerned, you’re not alone. But concern without action is just worry.
Here’s what forward-thinking leaders are doing right now:
- Training all interviewers on proper techniques and legal boundaries
- Implementing structured interviews with consistent questions
- Using validated behavioral assessments to complement interviews
- Creating clear job descriptions focusing on essential functions
- Developing interview guides with legally-compliant questions
And for those serious about transforming their hiring process into a competitive advantage, I’m excited to share a resource that’s helped hundreds of my clients do exactly that.
Join our email list to download a free copy of The Interviewer’s Handbook.
Take Your Interviewing Skills to the Next Level
The Interviewer’s Handbook provides everything you need to conduct effective, legally-compliant interviews that identify top talent even in challenging markets. Inside, you’ll discover:
– Proven structured interview frameworks that minimize bias
– Behavioral assessment tools that predict job performance
– Candidate search strategies to find hidden talent
– Engagement plans to keep your best hires motivated
Plus, take the free Workplace Personality Assessment included to understand your own interviewing style and potential blind spots.
In uncertain times, the companies that thrive are those that hire smarter than their competition. This handbook gives you the edge you need.
Let’s Connect
What’s your biggest interviewing challenge? Drop a comment below or reach out directly—I personally respond to every message.
Because in today’s climate, we can’t afford to just exchange business cards at conferences once a year. Real connections and continuous improvement are how we’ll weather whatever economic and political changes come our way.
Gareth Callaway is President of Gateway, with over 25 years of experience in talent acquisition and recruiting. He specializes in using behavioral science to build high-performing teams across industries.
Like what you just read? There’s more where that came from—think of it as your next favorite rabbit hole.
The early bird loses the worm? Rethinking punctuality in professional settings
Gareth Callaway
PRESIDENT
